This is the archived version of the Milk Street website and is no longer up to date.

Please visit 177milkstreet.com to see the current website with all of the latest recipes!

ADVERTISEMENT

This is the archived version of the Milk Street website and is no longer up to date.

Please visit 177milkstreet.com to see the current website with all of the latest recipes!

Sweet Potato Gratin with Vanilla Bean and Bay Leaves

8 Servings

3 hours 50 min active

Made This Recipe? Write a Review.
Thank you for submitting your review! A member of our team is confirming the review meets our site's Community Guidelines. It will be posted on the site shortly.

For many families, Thanksgiving isn’t complete without a sweet potato casserole, that sticky-sweet concoction more appropriate for the dessert table than the main event. It’s a classic for good reason, though we felt the gooey marshmallows had to go. We started by roasting the sweet potatoes, a simple, hands-off process that can be done a day ahead. Roasting rather than boiling produces cleaner, deeper flavors and a better, less watery texture. In lieu of marshmallows we infuse cream with vanilla bean and bay leaves and add a dusting of black pepper for an overall effect that hints at marshmallow but is far more nuanced, compelling and aromatic. A crunchy topping of dark brown and white sugar with a touch of cayenne keeps the dish adults table-appropriate. We found that using a mesh strainer to sift the sugar over the potatoes produced even browning and an attractive crust. But strainers with very fine mesh tended to clog. If yours does this, just sprinkle the sugar by hand, smoothing it into an even layer with your palm.

8

Servings

Tip

Don’t get distracted while the gratin is broiling; all broilers are different, and the difference between browned and burnt can be a matter of seconds.

3 hours

50 min active

Ingredients

  • 5

    pounds sweet potatoes

  • 1

    cup heavy cream

Directions

Reviews
MEGAN S.
November 28, 2025
Delicious
The bay added a wonderful flavor.
JUDITH Y.
November 28, 2025
Update!
I DID make this with butternut squash, and per suggestion, I did reduce the amount of cream a bit, and the results were DELICIOUS! Everyone loved the little hint of cayenne, and after an initial grumble or two about the lack of marshmallows, it got lots of compliments! I'd make again in a heartbeat!
JUDITH Y.
November 16, 2025
Can I sub Squash
This sounds so delicious! My husband can no longer eat sweet potatoes for medical reasons. Could I substitute butternut or delicata squash?
STEVE K.
November 12, 2025
quick question Re: step 2
I'm going to try this as my one allowable new dish this year. In Step 2 it says bring to a simmer over medium high. For how long? Or just bring to a simmer, then remove from the heat and set aside, covered for 30 min? Sorry. It's not clear.
Kristie M.
October 24, 2025
A family favorite
I have made this every year at Thanksgiving since it was first published and it is a crowd favorite. My youngest son has even started to ask for it as part of his birthday dinner each year (in July). I make the sweet potato puree the day before Thanksgiving to help with meal management on the day-of, and this is the rare recipe to which I don't add any personal touches--it's absolutely perfect as written.
Thomas F.

I had accidentally commented on the wrong recipe before, but I wanted to say I highly recommend this recipe. One of the best milk street recipes I’ve made. I’ll be insisting on making this on future holidays for a while.

Lynn C.

Hi Diana. -

No, this is not a dessert, it's our twist on a traditional Thanksgiving side.

Best,
The Milk Street Team

Laeticia C.

Can I substitute the dark brown sugar for light brown? Does this affect the amount of white sugar I use if I do so?

Lynn C.

Hi Laeticia -

Substituting with light brown sugar probably won't make a huge difference in this case. It just won't have as strong a "caramel-like" flavor.

Best,
The Milk Street Team


ADVERTISEMENT