This is the archived version of the Milk Street website and is no longer up to date.

Please visit 177milkstreet.com to see the current website with all of the latest recipes!

ADVERTISEMENT

This is the archived version of the Milk Street website and is no longer up to date.

Please visit 177milkstreet.com to see the current website with all of the latest recipes!

Pumpkin Pie with Honey-Orange Whipped Cream

Makes one 9-inch pie

1 hour 40 minutes 40 minutes active, plus cooling

Made This Recipe? Write a Review.
Thank you for submitting your review! A member of our team is confirming the review meets our site's Community Guidelines. It will be posted on the site shortly.

We love pumpkin pie, but we don’t love how dense, cloying and overspiced it can be. We wanted a lighter, fresher take with a pronounced pumpkin flavor. Canned pumpkin puree was a great place to start, but we intensified its flavor by giving it a quick sauté with dark brown sugar. This cooks off excess moisture and lends caramel notes to the mixture. A little bourbon adds complexity that complements the earthiness of the pumpkin and brown sugar, but an equal amount of orange juice works well, too. To give the filling tang and richness, we add crème fraîche instead of the typical evaporated milk. Honey-sweetened, citrus-scented whipped cream (recipe follows) is the perfect accompaniment.

Makes one

9-inch pie

Tip

Don’t use canned pumpkin pie filling for this recipe. Look for unsweetened canned pumpkin puree; the only ingredient listed should be pumpkin. After adding the bourbon to the skillet, stir carefully if you're using a gas burner, as splashes may cause the liquid to ignite. If this happens, the flames will extinguish after a few seconds, once the alcohol has burned off.

1 hour 40 minutes

40 minutes active, plus cooling

Ingredients

  • 15

    ounce can pumpkin puree

  • 149

    grams (¾ cup packed) dark brown sugar

Directions

Reviews
PAULA R.
December 8, 2025
Good variation on pumpkin pie.
We like this. Less sweet and the honey orange whipped cream is so good. Something different from the standard pumpkin pie which we also like.
SARAH N.
November 29, 2025
Excellent Pumpkin Pie!
I have made this twice with great results both times. I did add a few fall spices but not in large amounts. Some nutmeg and cinnamon. I made the orange whipped cream and my husband said he didn’t like it because it took away from the pie flavor (he just wants regular old whipped cream) but others loved it. I think it’s about whether you are a traditionalist or not. Next year I will make both types of whipped cream. I say this is a keeper!
Jacki K.
February 11, 2025
A Perfect Slice
Simple yet company worthy & delicious. Easy to make & the crust is crisp then melts in your mouth. I made the honey orange whipped too & it's not to be missed.
Amy G.
November 29, 2024
My new favorite!
I love pumpkin pie. It has been my go-to holiday dessert since I was a kid. However, the pumpkin spice craze has made me feel like there's been pumpkin overload. This recipe was so easy, not overly sweet, and the perfect consistency. It was a hit at our family Thanksgiving this year! As I always say, Milk Street hasn't steered me wrong yet!
Joe K.
November 24, 2024
Luscious!
So easy to make, such a warm and wonderful aroma in my kitchen and simply luscious taste. I thought my bourbon pecan pie was good but I’ll now this pie to my holiday (and every day) rotation. Thank you for sharing with us.

ADVERTISEMENT